Why the wealth siphon must end. Be ended: a new vision for the red-green left.

In Game Changer, Jennifer Hinton argues that privately-owned, for-profit companies—whose legal purpose is extracting surplus profit for private shareholders—are at the root of today’s severe social and ecological crises. She contends that these firms cannot simply be regulated or “contained” through Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR), B-Corps, or taxation, but must be dispensed with and phased out altogether.

I agree with her. This change should be the at the center of Red-Green coalitions everywhere. Capitalism with this extractive modus operandi has shown itself to not deliver decent standard of living for all, within what the planet can absorb. Up until now, socialism has been relegated to being a mattress for the victims of this dark game.

This can no longer go on. With the discovery of MMT – Modern Monetary Theory – we can dispense with right-wing politics and usher in a new vision, thanks to Hinton’s book.

Before we look at solutions, in case you are not quite yet convinced this set-up, sometimes called the capitalist law of value is totally destructive.


Part 1: Why For-Profit Companies Are Bad for Society

Hinton lays out seven primary, interconnected reasons why shareholder-driven businesses systematically damage society:

1. The “Wealth Siphon” and Escalating Inequality

  • Siphoning Wealth Out of the Real Economy: Surplus value generated by workers and consumers is continuously extracted to enrich private owners and shareholders.
  • Elite Hoarding: Shareholders accumulate wealth in private savings, luxury real estate, and financial assets rather than reinvesting it productively in communities.
  • The Growth Imperative: Because wealth is constantly drained from the regular economy by this “wealth siphon,” the economy is forced into endless, unnatural growth just to maintain baseline employment and public revenues—a trap Hinton calls “a snake eating its own tail”.

2. Cost-Shifting and Worker Exploitation

  • Wage Suppression: To maximize dividends for investors and bonuses for managers, firms actively suppress worker pay, cut healthcare and pensions, block unions, and replace stable jobs with gig work.
  • “Cost-Shifting” Fraud: What companies call “cost-cutting” is actually shifting the costs of low wages, poor health, and environmental cleanup onto workers, public safety nets, and nature while owners keep the profit.
  • Vicious Wage-Price Cycles: Low wages force households to buy cheap, poor-quality goods, which in turn rely on underpaid or forced labor to remain cheap.

3. Manufactured Overconsumption & Consumerism

  • Engineering Artificial Needs: To satisfy investor demands for quarterly sales growth, firms manufacture demand using manipulative advertising (including targeting young children).
  • Planned Obsolescence & Addictive Products: Companies deliberately build products to wear out or break quickly, and use addictive additives (in junk food or pharmaceuticals) or dopamine-driven digital algorithms to keep consumers dependent.
  • Psychological & Social Damage: This culture of consumerism degrades personal mental health—increasing anxiety, loneliness, and insecurity—while eroding community ties.

4. Ecological Overshoot and Waste Colonialism

  • Linear Resource Destruction: The for-profit engine operates on a destructive “take-make-use-dispose” cycle that strips raw materials, destroys ecosystems, and produces billions of tons of waste.
  • Growth vs. Nature: Profit-driven competition forces endless expansion regardless of ecological cost, driving climate breakdown, ocean acidification, and mass species extinction.
  • Waste Colonialism: High-income corporate economies ship toxic electronics, plastic trash, and discarded textiles to low-income countries where regulations are weak and labor is cheap.

5. Political Capture and Erosion of Democracy

  • Buying the Rules: Corporations invest billions in lobbying politicians, corrupting regulatory agencies via revolving doors, and securing tax breaks and subsidies.
  • Shadow Legal Systems: Multinationals use Investor-State Dispute Settlements (ISDS) in trade agreements to sue democratic governments in private arbitration courts whenever public safety, wage, or environmental laws threaten corporate profits.
  • Pillaging Public Services: Corporate lobbying pushes to privatize healthcare, housing, water, and education, transforming essential human rights into revenue streams.

6. Market Concentration and Collusion

  • “Winner-Takes-Most” Dynamics: Profit maximization naturally leads to mergers, acquisitions, and monopolies that crush or swallow up smaller, locally-rooted businesses.
  • Cartels and Price-Fixing: Rather than competing fairly, dominant players routinely collude to fix prices, rig public bids, and limit supply because collusion is more profitable than competition.

7. Neglect of Human Needs for Unnecessary Luxury

  • Profit Over Survival: Because capital flows to where returns are highest, vast resources are funneled into luxury goods and minor cosmetic products (e.g., anti-aging or hair loss treatments) while life-saving medicines for tropical diseases, clean water, and affordable housing are neglected because poor communities cannot generate high profit margins.

Part 2: Why Containment Is Not Enough (Why They Must Be Dispensed With)

Many economists and reformists suggest containing for-profit firms through stricter regulations, higher taxes, CSR, or B-Corps. Hinton argues these “fixes” fail because they attempt to patch a system whose foundational objective is flawed:

  • 1. The Systemic Fighting of Regulation: Regulations and taxes directly conflict with the core objective of a for-profit firm (private financial gain). Because for-profit firms hold vast wealth, they will always use lobbying, tax havens, and legal loopholes to resist, water down, or circumvent regulatory limits faster than governments can enact them.
  • 2. The Rebound Effect & Green Growth Myth: Technological efficiency under a profit motive does not reduce ecological footprints; it makes goods cheaper to produce, causing companies to sell and consume even more in total—negating efficiency gains.
  • 3. Structural Contradiction in B-Corps and Social Enterprises: For-profit social enterprises face an unavoidable legal conflict between serving society and enriching investors. Studies show that when trade-offs arise, investor financial returns consistently take priority over social missions.
  • 4. “Enabling Charity” Dependency: Non-profits and charities rely on funding from the very for-profit market that creates social breakdown, rendering civil society dependent on corporate interests and serving as a reputation wash for polluting or exploitative companies.
  • 5. Market Contagion & Loopholes: Allowing even a small fraction of for-profit firms to exist creates loopholes that get exploited (as seen with OpenAI or IKEA). For-profit companies force everyone else into a “race to the bottom,” forcing ethical businesses and non-profits to abandon their missions just to stay solvent.
  • 6. Inability to Exist in a Steady-State Economy: A sustainable, post-growth economy requires stabilizing production within planetary boundaries. For-profit companies require perpetual expansion to pay out dividends, making them structurally incompatible with planetary survival.

Hinton concludes that trying to make a for-profit economy sustainable is like “racing to put out individual fires while a pyromaniac douses the area in gasoline”. The solution is not to manage the arsonist, but to remove the matches and transition to an entirely Not-for-Profit Economy

Leave a Reply